Do Promotions Make Consumers More Generous?

Giving Tuesday, a global generosity movement, takes place each year on the Tuesday after U.S. Thanksgiving (immediately after Black Friday and Cyber Monday sales). Charitable donations generally see a big boost on Giving Tuesday. This year, American consumers donated a total of US$2.47 billion on Giving Tuesday to various charitable causes, including $808 million in donations made online. 
 
Giving Tuesday was initiated by the 92nd Street Y and United Nations Foundation in the post-Thanksgiving season as a response to growing concerns about the consumerism and materialism associated with Black Friday and Cyber Monday sales. Given the large sales volume achieved in these promotion events, the media has portrayed Black Friday as America’s greediest holiday. As a result, several retailers and organizations have called for boycotts of Black Friday and Cyber Monday sales, arguing that Black Friday not only ruins the spirit of Thanksgiving, but also decreases social welfare by making consumers stingier and more selfish. 
 
An important question thus arises: Can price promotions lead to potential positive social consequences and contribute to a better world? In a new study in the Journal of Marketing, our research team shows that price promotions can have a positive effect on consumers’ donation behavior because the monetary savings from price promotions increase consumers’ perceived resources. Further, we show that the positive effect of price promotions on consumers’ donation behavior is stronger when consumers focus on the amount of money saved, when the purchase falls within their budget, and when the monetary savings can be realized immediately. We also show that charitable organizations can benefit the most when they solicit donations immediately after price promotions. Our findings not only help explain the success of Giving Tuesday, but also provide insights to other organizations about the best timing for their charitable campaigns. 
 
Specifically, our findings help charitable organizations make three important decisions:

1. who to target (consumers who have participated in price promotions);
2. when to solicit donations (immediately after consumers make purchases); and
3. how to increase effectiveness (charitable organizations should pair their donation appeals with promotions for necessities (vs. indulgences) that offer immediate discounts (vs. future rebates)).

Further, the donation appeals should direct consumers’ focus toward the money they saved (vs. spent) in the promotion. Charitable organizations can take advantage of these insights to better optimize their donation appeals.

Our research also suggests that firms can use price promotions as great opportunities to collaborate with charitable organizations. For example, the outdoor brand Patagonia has committed since 2016 to donate 100% of its profits from Black Friday to charities. Unfortunately, in traditional cause-related marketing practices, consumers might doubt a firm’s prosocial motivation because the benefits for the charity are contingent on consumers’ purchases from the firm. Our findings suggest that by soliciting donations after consumers complete their purchases, firms can cultivate a purer image of corporate social responsibility. This strategy was exemplified recently by Ralph Lauren, which partnered with the World Health Organization to fight against the COVID-19 pandemic by soliciting donations from customers immediately after they submitted their orders on the store’s official online shop. This collaborative strategy between firms and nonprofit organizations can create a win-win situation that benefits stakeholders and contributes to a better world.

Read the full article. 

Read the authors’ slides for sharing this material in your classroom.

From: Kuangjie Zhang, Fengyan Cai, and Zhengyu Shi, “Do Promotions Make Consumers More Generous? The Impact of Price Promotions on Consumers’ Donation Behavior,” Journal of Marketing.

Go to the Journal of Marketing